---
title: "ULA's preliminary review points to fuel supply in Vulcan loss of 40 satellites"
url: "https://nova-maind.com/articles/1265"
published: "2026-11-19"
updated: "2026-11-19"
category: "Space"
tags: ["United Launch Alliance", "Vulcan", "BE-4", "Blue Origin", "Amazon Leo", "Launch Investigation"]
publisher: "NovΔ mAInd (https://nova-maind.com)"
---

# ULA's preliminary review points to fuel supply in Vulcan loss of 40 satellites

> United Launch Alliance says preliminary data show low booster thrust came from inadequate fuel supply to the BE-4 engines, not engine performance, in the Nov. 15 Vulcan failure that lost 40 Amazon Leo satellites.

United Launch Alliance (ULA) said on Nov. 18 that its preliminary integrated review of the Nov. 15 Vulcan launch anomaly indicates the vehicle supplied inadequate fuel to the two BE-4 engines on the first stage, rather than the engines themselves underperforming. The failure cost the mission all 40 Amazon Leo satellites.

### Low booster thrust traced to fuel delivery, not the engines

ULA reported it lost telemetry approximately 10 minutes into flight, and that the vehicle experienced low booster performance shortly after liftoff. When stage separation occurred the vehicle was already low in altitude and below the velocity needed to reach orbit.

In its statement ULA said the RL10 upper-stage engines built by Aerojet Rocketdyne, the BE-4 engines built by Blue Origin, and the Northrop Grumman solid rocket boosters all operated as planned based on preliminary data. “Preliminary indications are that the low booster thrust was the result of inadequate fuel supply from the vehicle to the BE-4 engines, not from the performance of the engines,” ULA said.

The company noted the Vulcan second stage (Centaur V) appears to have started nominally and the RL10s were operating as planned, but could not recover from the earlier loss of first-stage performance. ULA also said the six solid rocket boosters used for this mission appear to have performed nominally; those SRBs had been upgraded after an anomaly on Vulcan’s February flight.

The Federal Aviation Administration has initiated a mishap review of the failed launch and is overseeing the ULA-led investigation. ULA emphasized that work remains to determine root cause and that it will provide updates when more information is available.

### From “very early” to a preliminary finding in three days

The Nov. 18 update goes further than ULA's first diagnosis. As NovΔ mAInd reported in [ULA's Vulcan Centaur failed after low first-stage performance, 40 Amazon Leo satellites lost](https://nova-maind.com/articles/1259), ULA said on Nov. 17 that early data pointed to low booster performance in the core first stage. At that point it stopped short of blaming the engines, saying it was very early in the investigation and that it wanted to avoid speculation. The FAA must approve the final report and any corrective actions.

As we reported in [ULA's Vulcan fails on fifth flight, losing 40 Amazon Leo satellites](https://nova-maind.com/articles/1249), the rocket lifted off from Space Launch Complex 41 at Cape Canaveral Space Force Station at 12:40 p.m. EST. It flew as a VC6L, the most powerful Vulcan configuration, with six GEM-63XL solid boosters, two BE-4 engines burning liquid oxygen and methane, and a low-Earth-orbit-optimized Centaur V. The solids burned out and fell away normally about a minute and 40 seconds into flight. Spaceflight Now reported that the first stage appeared to burn longer than planned. ULA has not confirmed that detail.

The flight was only Vulcan's fifth, and its first in nine months, a gap spent on nozzle problems with the Northrop Grumman strap-on boosters.

### Blue Origin's valve fix and Amazon's 38-launch plan

Blue Origin, which supplies the BE-4 engines used on Vulcan and on its own New Glenn vehicle, previously traced a separate engine-related anomaly to a main oxygen valve issue on a BE-4 engine during testing. The company completed qualification testing on a modified valve in early November and said the modified valve has been incorporated into engines slated for upcoming flights. After ULA’s Nov. 18 update, Blue Origin CEO Dave Limp released a statement acknowledging the disappointing outcome and praising the BE-4 team for their rapid response and support of ULA’s investigation.

The Nov. 15 failure was ULA’s first full mission loss in the company’s history and occurred during Vulcan’s return-to-flight campaign following a monthslong grounding. The launch was the first Vulcan mission for Amazon Leo and was to be the initial launch in a 38-flight plan for Amazon, which has contracted Vulcan to carry more than 1,500 of its first-generation satellites. Amazon Leo had previously flown eight missions on Atlas V. Across other rockets, Amazon has launched 396 Leo satellites on 14 successful missions.

NovΔ mAInd's launch database lists United Launch Alliance with 12 launches tracked, a 91.7% success rate and a most recent launch on 2026-11-15, at 28000 kg to LEO.

## Sources

- https://www.satellitetoday.com/launch/2026/11/18/ula-reports-launch-failure-not-tied-to-engine-issue/

---
Source: NovΔ mAInd (https://nova-maind.com/articles/1265)
